Skip to main content

Table 1 The baseline characteristics of identified studies and involved patients

From: Comparisons of open surgical repair, thoracic endovascular aortic repair, and optimal medical therapy for acute and subacute type B aortic dissection: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Study

Study design

Region

Sample size

Mean age (years)

Male (%)

Hypertension (%)

CAD (%)

MS (%)

Prior AD (%)

DM (%)

Aneurysm (%)

Disease status

Treated aortic segments

Intervention

Follow-up (months)

Dialetto 2005 [22]

Retro

Italy

56

58.7

83.9

80.4

NA

NA

1.8

NA

NA

Acute

Unclear

TEVAR; OMT

18.1

Hsu 2005 [23]

Retro

China

107

58.4

82.0

NA

NA

2.8

NA

NA

NA

Acute

Unclear

OSR; OMT

36.1

Tsai 2006 [24]

Retro

11 countries

242

62.1

69.0

70.2

NA

3.3

7.0

5.0

15.3

Acute

Arch involvement: 12

OSR; TEVAR; OMT

27.6

Nienabler 2009 [25]

Pro

Germany, Italy, France

140

60.2

84.3

12.9

NA

1.4

NA

7.9

NA

Acute and subacute

Descending thoracic aorta: 13

TEVAR; OMT

24.0

Patel 2009 [26]

Retro

USA

69

65.9

59.4

73.9

26.1

NA

13.0

11.6

31.9

Acute

Arch aorta: 46; descending aorta: 33

OSR; TEVAR

37.4

Chemelli-Steingruber 2010 [27]

Retro

Austria

88

64.6

75.0

78.4

23.9

NA

NA

8.0

NA

Acute

Unclear

TEVAR; OMT

33.0–36.0

Garbade 2010 [28]

Retro

Germany

135

65.0

74.8

94.1

NA

NA

NA

19.3

73.3

Acute

Arch involvement: 5; descending aorta: 131

OSR; TEVAR; OMT

36.9

Mastroroberto 2010 [29]

Retro

Italy

24

72.4

62.5

79.2

8.3

NA

8.3

12.5

NA

Acute

Unclear

OSR; TEVAR

47.2

Zeeshan 2010 [30]

Retro

USA

77

59.6

70.1

79.2

16.9

NA

NA

13.0

18.2

Acute

Unclear

OSR; TEVAR; OMT

37.0

Sachs 2010 [31]

Retro

USA

50,00

60.7

65.6

67.7

3.7

NA

NA

7.6

NA

Acute and subacute

Unclear

OSR; TEVAR

36.0

Conrad 2010 [32]

Retro

USA

2,701

70.9

57.8

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

Acute and subacute

Descending aorta

OSR; TEVAR

60.0

Narayan 2011 [33]

Retro

UK

84

56.7

75.0

50.0

8.3

4.8

NA

2.4

48.8

Acute and subacute

Descending aorta

OSR; TEVAR

24.4

Nozdrzykowski 2013 [34]

Retro

Germany

80

63.0

73.7

98.8

21.3

5.0

27.5

20.0

66.2

Acute

Descending aorta

OSR; TEVAR; OMT

42.0

Wilkinson 2013 [35]

Retro

USA

73

66.2

63.0

80.8

26.0

NA

24.7

11.0

100.0

Acute and subacute

Arch aorta: 57; descending aorta: 32

OSR; TEVAR

27.7

Shah 2014 [36]

Retro

USA

4,706

67.0

55.0

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

Acute

Unclear

TEVAR; OMT

24.0–60.0

Brunkwall 2014 [37]

Pro

UK

61

63.0

78.7

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

Acute

Descending aorta

TEVAR; OMT

12.0

Afifi 2015 [38]

Retro

USA

442

60.2

62.0

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

Acute

Descending aorta

OSR; TEVAR; OMT

55.2

Chou 2015 [39]

Retro

China

1,661

58.5

70.3

71.8

NA

NA

NA

8.8

NA

Acute and subacute

Descending aorta

OSR; TEVAR

48.0

Qin 2016 [40]

Retro

China

338

60.7

89.3

47.0

11.5

NA

NA

10.4

NA

Acute

Descending aorta: 34; extended to abdominal aorta: 304

TEVAR; OMT

29.9–39.5

Song 2016 [41]

Retro

China

252

53.6

81.7

76.6

3.6

0.8

NA

6.7

2.8

Acute

Descending aorta

TEVAR; OMT

60.0

Zhu 2016 [42]

Retro

China

118

52.7

72.9

93.2

30.5

NA

NA

9.3

NA

Acute and subacute

Descending aorta: 63; arch aortic: 43

OSR; TEVAR

56.0

Iannuzzi 2018 [43]

Retro

USA

9,165

66.0

60.8

66.6

NA

NA

NA

12.4

NA

Acute

Unclear

OSR; TEVAR; OMT

18.0–27.6

Lou 2018 [44]

Retro

USA

318

57.7

67.3

92.8

NA

1.6

NA

15.7

NA

Acute

Unclear

OSR; TEVAR; OMT

27.6

Xiang 2021 [45]

Retro

China

357

54.4

79.6

64.7

7.6

NA

NA

4.5

NA

Acute

Descending aorta

TEVAR; OMT

38.4–45.6

Wei 2022 [46]

Pro

China

90

49.7

66.7

54.4

4.4

NA

NA

7.8

NA

Acute

Descending aorta

TEVAR; OMT

24.0

Tang 2023 [47]

Retro

China

729

54.6

85.5

79.7

9.6

0.6

NA

7.5

NA

Acute and subacute

Unclear

TEVAR; OMT

58.9

Tian 2023 [48]

Retro

China

105

46.0

82.9

94.3

4.8

NA

NA

2.9

1.9

Acute and subacute

Unclear

OSR; TEVAR

12.0

Lou 2023 [49]

Retro

USA

146

57.1

67.1

91.1

NA

NA

NA

11.6

NA

Acute

Descending aorta, abdominal aorta

TEVAR; OMT

51.6

Weissler 2023 [50]

Retro

USA

7,105

75.7

44.2

35.7

17.9

NA

NA

8.6

NA

Acute

Unclear

TEVAR; OMT

60.0

Ahmad 2024 [51]

Retro

Germany

53

61.1

58.5

92.5

11.3

NA

NA

0.0

NA

Acute and subacute

Unclear

TEVAR; OMT

26.0

Krebs 2024 [52]

Retro

USA

159

59.0

77.0

82.0

6.0

NA

NA

18.0

NA

Acute

Unclear

TEVAR; OMT

36.0

  1. Abbreviation: AD Aortic dissection, CAD Coronary artery disease, COPD Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, DM Diabetes mellitus, MS Marfan syndrome, NA Not available, OMT Best medical therapy, OSR Open surgical repair, Pro, Prospective, Retro Retrospective, TEVAR Thoracic endovascular aortic repair